The short-term rental market used to be forgiving. A decent property, good photos, and an Airbnb listing were often enough to earn steady income. That era is ending. New listings have slowed sharply, yet operators say the pressure hasn’t eased. Increasingly, the market rewards hosts who run their rentals like businesses and pushes out those who don’t.
Part of the explanation is local. The markets adding listings fastest early this year, including Florida beach destinations, also saw the steepest drops in occupancy. The other part is that the bar for running a rental has risen. Frank Bosi, senior director of partner development at Hostfully, a property management software company, says owners who expected passive income are finding that guests now expect more.
“A few years ago, you could put a decent property on Airbnb; you could take some pretty good, high-quality pictures and do pretty well,” Bosi says. “And that’s just not the reality of it anymore.”
From Volume to Profitability
Bosi says success is now measured differently. Operators used to count how many properties they managed. Now the question is how much each property actually earns. “We’re seeing the shift away from just really focusing on how many properties you manage to focusing now on how profitable those properties actually are,” he says.
Conditions vary by market. Bosi says seasonal destinations such as parts of Florida have strong months followed by sharp drop-offs, while year-round markets draw more listings competing for the same guests. He adds that regulations have weighed on many operators.
Slower supply growth is also changing who benefits. The slowdown, combined with healthy travel demand, has supported occupancy and strengthened pricing for established operators. Revenue per listing is expected to grow modestly this year, and most of that growth comes from higher nightly rates rather than more booked nights. In other words, operators are earning more by charging more, not by filling more of their calendars. Last year, by contrast, nightly rates rose more slowly than inflation, which meant hosts were effectively earning less per night in real terms.
A New Revenue Strategy
One adjustment with clear market support is blending short-term and midterm stays in the same property. Monthly stays have grown from a niche into a meaningful share of overall rental demand, and they are growing faster than traditional short stays. For owners, that opens a second pool of guests who book for weeks or months at a time, including during the slower months when vacation bookings drop off. Longer stays also mean fewer turnovers, fewer cleanings and less day-to-day guest communication.
Bosi says this demand comes from traveling professionals, people relocating for work, families displaced by insurance claims, and seasonal residents. Some operators in seasonal markets list short-term during peak months and switch to monthly stays during slower periods.
Bosi says property managers are realizing “they don’t necessarily have to choose between short-term rental and midterm rentals.” He adds: “Depending on the market and the property, there can really be a big opportunity to do both.”
The Underestimated Workload
Bosi says he has seen many owners sell rather than adapt, and that the reason they give is usually the same: the job turned out to be more work than they expected. Turnovers, reviews, guest communication and maintenance add up. “A lot of people underestimate the work involved with short-term rentals,” he says.
He sees the same pattern as a traveler. He and his wife spend part of every summer at Oak Island on the Carolina coast and choose a different rental each year, partly on purpose, to see how each host handles the stay. Most treat it as check-in and check-out. “Those individuals are looking at their property as just a place to stay,” he says. “They’re not thinking about the experience, and they’re not thinking about the repeat business and the revenue that it can generate.”
Winning repeat business through the major platforms has become more constrained. Airbnb’s off-platform policy bars hosts from moving current, future, or repeat bookings off the platform. For reservations made on or after November 20, 2026, hosts can no longer ask guests for a phone number, email, or home address, except in limited cases. That puts more weight on the stay itself, and on the reviews that follow it, as the reason a guest comes back.
Where AI Fits
Operators expect automation to shape the coming year. In a recent industry survey, hosts and property managers ranked automation and AI as the most significant factors for the industry in 2026, ahead of regulation and changes in travel demand.
Bosi separates practical uses from hype. “What excites me isn’t necessarily the flashy AI stuff,” he says. “It’s the practical operations, it’s the little things.” He points to responding to guests faster, automating repetitive tasks, and researching market revenue opportunities that would otherwise take hours.
He is also clear that technology has limits. “Technology should definitely enhance that experience, but it should definitely not replace it,” he says. “The operators who figure out how to combine great technology with great hospitality are those that you’re seeing to have a real advantage.”
Building for Durability
Bosi’s advice to operators is to resist adopting every new tool at once. “You don’t need to implement every new technology or chase every new trend,” he says. “Sometimes it’s the small, intentional steps that really make the biggest difference.” He describes himself as “confidently optimistic” about the industry, though he expects it to look different than it did five years ago.
The national numbers support a version of that outlook. With new supply growing at its slowest pace in years, the market’s next phase is less about getting in early and more about running well. The advantage goes to operators who already price carefully, use their calendars fully across short and longer stays, and give guests a reason to leave a good review.
About the Expert: Frank Bosi is senior director of partner development at Hostfully in Charlotte, North Carolina, focusing on technology partnerships and property manager relationships.
This article is based on information provided by the expert source cited above. It is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or real estate advice. Readers should conduct their own research and consult qualified professionals before making any real estate or financial decisions.