Buyers looking in the small towns north of Greensboro, North Carolina – Summerfield, Oak Ridge, and Stokesdale – find highly regarded schools and lower tax bills, but few homes at moderate prices. Homes in Summerfield average about $625,000, and new construction averages closer to $850,000. “Summerfield can always use homes that are not as expensive as $600,000,” says Betty Smith, co-owner of Smith Marketing, Inc. at Howard Hanna Allen Tate. “It would be great to have more opportunities for homes that are less than $500,000.”
The shortage traces back to decisions made long before a house reaches the market: whether public water and sewer lines reach the land, what rules a developer attaches to a neighborhood, and how much building now costs. Smith’s team advises developers on what to build and then sells the finished homes, so it watches those decisions take shape from the start.
Why Buyers Keep Coming
The pressure on prices starts with demand. Smith calls the area’s schools highly sought after and a dominant factor in its growth as Greensboro has spread outward. Taxes add to the pull: Summerfield residents pay only county taxes, while Greensboro residents pay both city and county taxes – a considerable difference in annual tax bills.
The typical buyer is an affluent family with school-age children making a second or third move up, and the area offers little downsizing product for anyone else. Many of those buyers arrive from out of state with money in hand. “A good number of the people we have moving in this area are people who are relocating with new industry,” Smith says.
Those well-funded newcomers raise the bar for everyone else. Many have already sold their previous homes before they arrive, and “a very large number of our buyers are paying cash for the homes,” Smith says. Local families, by contrast, usually need to sell their current homes before they can move up, and if their own buyers can’t qualify at higher interest rates, the whole chain stalls.
Without Pipes, Fewer Options
Demand alone doesn’t explain the price tags, because the land itself limits what builders can offer. Where public water and sewer lines don’t reach, every home needs its own well and septic system. Smith says townhomes and cluster homes become very difficult to build under those conditions, so the area consists primarily of larger single-family homes on larger lots. That leaves out the kinds of housing that typically sell for less.
Wider access to public utilities would change the mix. Where water and sewer are available, Smith says, a developer can put townhomes, cluster homes, and large-lot homes in the same neighborhood, giving buyers more than one price point to choose from. Without them, even a lower-priced project stays limited.
Crews are clearing land in Summerfield for a neighborhood of about 50 homes that Smith has heard will come in below the town’s usual price point, but because the site lacks water and sewer, she expects no added density there.
HOA Rules Raise Prices
Even where land is available, the developer’s rules for a neighborhood lock in much of a home’s cost before a builder ever prices it. Those rules, written into HOA documents, dictate how large homes must be and what they’re built from. A minimum of 3,000 square feet means no one can build a smaller, cheaper house there. A requirement that exteriors be 80 percent brick, rather than less expensive siding, raises the cost of every home on the street. “All those things, they start setting the level of what the cost of the homes in the neighborhood will be,” Smith says.
Volume builders can bring prices down by loosening those rules. When a regional or national builder controls every lot in a community, it writes the standards itself, and it might allow vinyl siding in place of brick and fiber-cement siding to lower the price.
Where Relief Might Come
In the near term, rising costs work against new supply. Smith says development costs have more than doubled in the last couple of years, and the price of gas and oil weighs heavily on both building materials and land development. Builders on her team have already pulled back somewhat because of unsold inventory, and she expects hesitation heading into 2027 and 2028, particularly in a market built around large homes on large lots.
Over the longer term, public water and sewer represent the biggest potential change, and the area has seen local discussion about expanding the reach of Greensboro’s water system. With strong schools, demand, and location already in place, Smith considers it nearly certain that water and sewer would bring growth to Summerfield. If plans to bring water and sewer into the area move forward, she says, “we anticipate that that would help a great deal.” Large projects planned just outside Summerfield’s limits could also add variety over time.
For buyers hoping to find a home under $500,000, the pipes are the change to watch, because townhomes and cluster homes can only follow where water and sewer go.
About the Expert: Betty Smith is co-owner of Smith Marketing, Inc. at Howard Hanna Allen Tate, based in Summerfield, North Carolina, where she specializes in new construction development and residential brokerage across the Triad.
This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or investment advice. The views and opinions expressed herein reflect those of the individuals quoted and do not represent an endorsement of any company, product, or service mentioned. Readers should conduct their own due diligence and consult qualified professionals before making any investment decisions.